登陆注册
6133700000039

第39章 Cloning: Good Science or Baaa ad Idea(1)

Ⅰ. Reading Str ategy: Dist ingu ishing Fa ct fr om Opinion

Facts and opinions are both used by a writer to support the main idea of a piece ofwriting. In order to attain a higher level of comprehension,you should acquire theability to distinguish facts from opinions in reading. With this ability,you can readcritically,so that you will not accept everything you read as fact.

A fact is a statement that can be proven true through objective evidence such asobservation or experimentation. It is also defined as something that actually exists,orthat everyone agrees is true. But it should be noticed that there are true facts and falsefacts . For example,the statement the sun moved around the ear th is obviously a falsefact as it has long been proven wrong.

An opinion,on the other hand,is a statement that cannot be objectively proventrue or false. It usually refers to one??s personal belief,feeling or judgment aboutsomething. An opinion,therefore,is open to debate even if it is based on fact. Thereare words that can serve as clues to statements of opinion. For example,words like Ibelieve,I think,in my opinion,I feel,and I suggest,show clearly that an opinionwill follow. Words like proba bly,perhaps,usua lly,often,sometimes,and onoccasion,are used to indicate the possibility of other opinions. Besides,opinionstatements usually have“ qualifier words”which represent opinions. Some of suchwords are: best,worst,great,ter rible,and wonder ful. However,looking for cluewords is far from enough for you to keep opinions from facts,as sometimes opinionsmay be masked as facts,which means they can be written so that they appear to befacts. This is especially true when someone is quoted. For example,Paul Freiberger,a technology expert,is quoted in Fuzzy Logic Sma rt Machines as follows: “ It??s atechnology that will change forever the way we deal with machines. ”This is just thespeaker??s opinion,one that would be shared by some people but not likely by all. Aquotation does not necessarily make a statement a fact. If a quotation is a fact,then itscontent must be factual. For example,you are dealing with a fact when Zadeh,acomputer science professor says in the same piece of writing,“ Computers dependupon exact information to do their work. We don??t. ”

Ⅱ. Applying the Read ing Str ategy

In this part,you are required to use the reading strategy you have just learned.

Read the following statements and decide whether they are facts or opinions.

1. The use of the motorcar is becoming more and more widespread in the twentiethcentury.

2. The feeling of independence,and the freedom to go where you please,is perhapsthe greatest advantage of the car .

3. Television is a great time-waster .

4. Television encourages passive enjoyment.

5. According to the August 10th issue of The Youth,out of 30,000 school graduatesin Shanghai who could take the college entrance examination this year ,only 23,000 sat for it.

6. There is not much point in going to college anyway because you can hardly everget an ideal job after you graduate.

7. Statistics show that rapid population growth creates problems for developingcountries.

8. It is only when people??s living standards begin to rise that birth rates begin to fall.

9. The housing reform gives the rich minority rather than the average majority achance to live better.

10. Vacant buildings ought to be turned into apartment buildings for the homeless.

Ⅲ. Reading Task

A. Pr e-r eading act ivity

Since the announcement of the birth of Dolly,the first mammal cloned from anadult cell,the fierce debate revolving around the issue of cloning a human being hasgreatly expanded. After being diagnosed with progressive lung disease,Dolly??s lifewas taken to an end by her creators. Her relatively early death in February 2003 fuelsthe debate. What??s your attitude towards human cloning? Do you think if scientistswill succeed in cloning a human in the near future in spite of people??s objections? Doyou agree or disagree that it??s worth the risk to clone a human being?

B. Reading

Prepare for disaster . That was the level of pessimism when veterinary researchersJonathan Hill and Mark Westhusin got ready to deliver the world??s first cloned bull atTexas A &M University a year and a half ago. And the scientists had good reason tobe pessimistic: several years of animal cloning work had taught them that most clonedanimals never even make it to birth,and the rare ones that do all too frequently haveproblems ranging from physical deformities to life-threatening medical conditions.This cream-colored calf,named Second Chance,was no exception.“ In his firstweek he was near death,” recalls Hill. He had underdeveloped lungs,like apremature baby. He had diabetes,anemia,a skin infection,and so many othercomplications that Hill can??t even recall them all. The calf spent his first few dayshooked up to intensive care machines.

Today,Second Chance grazes serenely in a pasture outside Austin,to allappearances just one more healthy bull in the herd. But if Second Chance??s healthproblems are behind him,many other animal clones have not fared so well. Indeed,the catalog of illnesses in cloned animals includes everything from blood vesselabnormalities and fatty livers to weak immune systems and deformed heads.

Such are the perils of taking cloning out of agricultural research labs and intofertility clinics. What if instead of Second Chance it had been a human baby hookedup to those life support machines? What if the baby had never recovered from thehealth problems,or indeed had died as many cloned animals do? The fierce debateover human cloning shifted from theoretical moral objections to practical safetyconcerns last week as researchers gathered in Italy for the first serious scientificmeeting devoted to human cloning.

Last week??s conference was organized by two experts with experience in cuttingedgereproductive technology; Panos Zavos,who runs a fertility clinic in Lexington,Ky. ,and Italian fertility doctor Severino Antinori. They plan to clone a human withintwo years,and many scientists don??t doubt that they??ll succeed.

同类推荐
  • 爱在尘埃堆积的角落

    爱在尘埃堆积的角落

    很多时候,爱就是这样简简单单的两三事。我牵着你的手,你靠着我的肩膀,刹那间,爱就是一切。过寻常日子,看细水长流。虽无声,却动人。
  • 那些难以忘怀的电影

    那些难以忘怀的电影

    该丛书由美国英语教师协会推荐,特点有三:内文篇目取自中外最经典、最权威、最流行的读本,适于诵读;“实战提升”部分,包括影片赏析、单词注解、脱口而出的句子,在重温经典中轻松掌握地道英语!
  • 英语PARTY——纯正口语对话室

    英语PARTY——纯正口语对话室

    本套书籍带你领略英语世界风景,感悟英语学习氛围,有助于英语学习。
  • 课外英语-高考必备词汇(双语版)

    课外英语-高考必备词汇(双语版)

    本套书共50册,分为美国各州的小知识,七彩缤纷的音符,优美好看的小散文,开心时分的短文,经典流传的寓言,超级高效的短句,实际有用的词汇等等在这些书中,备有单词解释,相关简介,或中文翻译,便于同学们更好的阅读和理解,真正进入文字的内涵当中,准确地和文字进行交流。本书主要分为地理小贴士、生活的角落和科技的发展等板块。本书介绍了高考必备词汇。
  • 魅力英文ⅵ:幸福从心开始

    魅力英文ⅵ:幸福从心开始

    本书收录了数十篇经典的英语美文,内容涉及生活、爱情、理想、亲情等方面,从不同的角度帮助你找到打开幸福大门的钥匙。书中选用的文章体裁多样,有语句优美的散文,像一道道清泉沁润你的心田;有感人至深的叙事文,让你领略人生的风景;也有世界权威研究中心的研究成果报告,让你的生活更加科学。
热门推荐
  • tfboys给我你的温柔

    tfboys给我你的温柔

    韩言曦脾气不好,不过对三只可不一样哦,因为是男神哦
  • 金鱼金鱼遇见你

    金鱼金鱼遇见你

    看了就知道怎么样了啊ww。。。。。。。。。。
  • 灵界天路

    灵界天路

    山中小子陈昊,偶得仙缘,拜入青阳。原本耿直寡言的少年,却偏偏碰到一群老不正经的师长,以及不着边际的损友。俗话说的好,“近猪会吃,近墨则黑”一个大好少年慢慢变成一个腹黑嘴贱的祸害。在青阳宗和几位好友组成“青阳四害”,走上了一条不归的爆笑修仙路。最后走出青阳,迈向天寒,跨入紫云,冲出北州,一路祸害到底………
  • 你和我的青涩岁月

    你和我的青涩岁月

    如你所见,我不是富家女。可这个一身贵气的清秀少年却握住我的手突然说“这才是我喜欢的人”,遭雷劈了吧。不过为嘛有一种莫名的窃喜,春心……萌动?什么?别扭又可爱!原来说的是我!罢了罢了,有什么事比心悦君子君亦如要更让人愉快的呢。哼哼,管你哪位阿三阿四,阿晏喜欢的是我。【某只偷香后】:“滋味怎么样?”“恩,挺甜的。”“去死,衣冠……”我咬牙切齿。“禽兽是吧。”某乖晏笑眯眯,“我只对你禽兽。”“……”承认吧骚年,你是不是又偷看我的小言情了。【ps:本文逗比,写的就一初恋,相信某桑,喜欢收藏,求推荐票】
  • 若梦浮生.

    若梦浮生.

    真爱上一个人,也就终于不再惧怕寂寞,当周遭的热闹归于平静,不要怕从此心空了,只要真爱不变,永远那个人会在寂寞处等你。“愿来生无梦再遇浮生。”看着女子纵身跳下往生崖,白衣飘诀的浮生将那红色衣影收入眼底,转身离去......“梦,你是我信仰,你不在我便不再。”芈珏痛恨那白衣男子,奈何自己始终是黑暗的使者,能做的怕是只有随梦一样的女子去......“纵然我是她,纵然我爱过你,那也是过去了,我如今愿的是无梦无你。”那红衣女子在风中决然抛下一句,凄冷决然......
  • 重生之天才医女

    重生之天才医女

    萧若情,现代中医世家的天才,从小跟在爷爷身边学习中医,等她27岁的时候已经青出于蓝而胜于蓝,只是当她的事业刚起步的时候,却因一次意外穿到了一个她未知的世界!萧若情,自小与母亲和哥哥萧云相依为命,是个古武天才,却在一次练武的时候走火入魔,香消玉殒了!
  • 终极系列之终极高校

    终极系列之终极高校

    俗话说,有人的地方就有江湖!只要有人,就有恩怨,有恩怨,就有江湖,人就是江湖!当然了,在2050年的今天,俗话是谁这个历史性的难题已经无从查究,但是他老人家的这句话已经流传了许久许久。在大的社会背景下,江湖s榜孕育而生,且看主角如何低调的穿梭在超能与平凡人的世界之中。
  • 狼族少年:狼王的女人你也敢动

    狼族少年:狼王的女人你也敢动

    狼族少年个个颜值不凡但对于问题女主来说似乎并没有什么卵用管你再帅!惹我就是死!
  • 薄情冷王独宠废妃

    薄情冷王独宠废妃

    一纸休书,他结束了他们一年的婚约,而他便转身迎娶了别的女人。三年后,她为了另一个男人,成为取悦别人的礼物,被送到了他身边,而一夜恩泽却将她推至风口浪尖。当他为了她不惜倾覆天下之时,而她却淡然一笑,转身离开。这本就是一场游戏,只是不知谁才是最后的赢家。
  • 低调的异能者

    低调的异能者

    “我不想修行,别逼我好吗?”穿越重生后的杨叶,意外的发现,自己这具不大的身体里面,竟然还住着一位邻居,而且,她还是一位身怀异能的女人!为了实现她的目标,悲催的杨叶被逼迫着,踏上了一段注定没有回头路的修行之旅。。。。